Will Centralus Health Merger Improve Care and Cut Costs for Patients?

January 24, 2025

On January 7, Cayuga Health and Arnot Health announced their intention to merge and form a new healthcare system named Centralus Health. This merger, which has been in the works since April 2023, is still awaiting regulatory approval from the New York State Department of Health (DOH). Despite the public announcement, the DOH has yet to grant the needed certificate of need (CON), though officials from Cayuga Health expect approval in the first half of 2025. Should the merger receive approval, Centralus Health would become a significant player in New York’s southern tier region, marking a potential turning point in local healthcare.

Assuming necessary approvals are granted, the merger will manage five hospitals across nine counties, facilitating approximately 847,000 outpatient appointments annually and overseeing $1 billion in medical services each year. Dr. Martin Stallone, CEO of Cayuga Health, is slated to become the CEO of Centralus Health, while Jonathan Lawrence, CEO of Arnot Health, will serve as the Executive Vice President. Centralus Health will remain non-profit and operate under a unified board of directors composed of members from both Cayuga and Arnot Health, striving to combine expertise and resources to benefit the community.

Expanding Access to Healthcare

The hospitals within the Centralus Health system will include Cayuga Medical Center in Ithaca, Schuyler Hospital in Montour Falls, Arnot Ogden Medical Center and St. Joseph’s Hospital in Elmira, and Ira Davenport Memorial Hospital in Bath. The merger aims to enhance access to healthcare, improve operational efficiencies, and reduce costs, addressing key issues such as rising operational expenses, workforce shortages, and the need for specialized care. According to Dr. Stallone, the merger represents a shared commitment to providing high-quality care to the communities served by these institutions.

One of the significant focuses of Centralus Health will be increasing access to primary care, particularly in Chemung and Tompkins counties. Part of this plan includes the implementation of the EPIC electronic health record system and MyChart patient portal, which are projected to launch in March 2025. These technological advancements are expected to streamline operations, reduce errors, and improve billing accuracy, ultimately leading to better patient care and cost efficiency. Such innovations are critical in ensuring that modern healthcare needs are met effectively, and patients across the region receive timely and accurate treatment.

Investment in Workforce and Infrastructure

Further, the new health system plans to invest in workforce development and capital improvements across its facilities. Expanded services will target critical healthcare areas such as cardiac care, cancer treatment, labor and delivery, behavioral health, and emergency care. The vision is to not just combine resources but to innovate and reimagine healthcare delivery for the communities served. Significant investments in infrastructure and technology are essential for building a robust healthcare system that can meet evolving healthcare demands while maintaining high standards of patient care.

Advocates of the merger believe that the consolidation will help address healthcare disparities in underserved regions while maintaining a high standard of care. However, there are concerns about potential downsides. Critics argue that consolidation within the healthcare industry can lead to higher prices and reduced quality of care due to decreased competition. Studies, like the one published in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons, have shown that hospital charges tend to increase post-merger, with little to no improvement in care quality. These studies highlight that while integration aims to control costs and enhance care quality, evidence suggests this is not always the outcome.

Addressing Potential Downsides

Specific concerns include the possibility of increased administrative costs and bureaucratic inefficiencies, which can complicate decision-making and divert resources from direct patient care. There’s also the worry that centralized decision-making might prioritize urban hubs, such as Ithaca and Elmira, to the detriment of smaller or rural communities. Dr. Stallone, however, has reassured that health equity initiatives will be expanded to more areas within Chemung and Steuben counties. This commitment to equity is critical in ensuring that all communities benefit equally from the merger, regardless of their geographic location.

In response to the merger, Guthrie Medical Group, a nearby health system that remains unaffiliated with Cayuga or Arnot, stated that while the merger has not yet received final approval, they are interested in understanding its impact after regulatory consideration. Guthrie, which operates across 12 counties with over 1,000 providers in more than 50 medical and surgical specialties, emphasized their ongoing commitment to provide comprehensive care. This highlights the complexities and competitive nature of healthcare consolidations, as other providers closely monitor developments to assess potential impacts on their operations and patient care.

Strategic Investments and Community Engagement

On January 7, Cayuga Health and Arnot Health declared their plan to merge, creating a new healthcare entity named Centralus Health. This merger has been in the pipeline since April 2023 and is currently pending approval from the New York State Department of Health (DOH). Despite the public announcement, the DOH has not yet issued the required certificate of need (CON). However, Cayuga Health officials anticipate receiving approval in the first half of 2025. If the merger is approved, Centralus Health will become a major player in the southern tier of New York, potentially revolutionizing local healthcare.

With the necessary approvals, the merger will oversee five hospitals across nine counties, managing roughly 847,000 outpatient visits annually and handling $1 billion in medical services each year. Dr. Martin Stallone, CEO of Cayuga Health, will step into the role of CEO for Centralus Health, while Jonathan Lawrence, CEO of Arnot Health, will become the Executive Vice President. Centralus Health will operate as a non-profit organization, guided by a unified board of directors from both Cayuga and Arnot Health, aiming to combine their expertise and resources for the community’s benefit.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later